Home Friday 3 Sep 2010  

Register





Lost Password?
No account yet? Register

Audiophilia

Fried fish fear follows black bean ban PDF Print E-mail
 

Written by Thingfish, on 15-11-2005 09:37


Hong Kong shoppers last week ran in fear as newspapers whipped up a three-day frenzy over cancerous canned carp.

Imagine the uproar that would erupt if Bush banned burgers or Blair barred baked beans. Such is the shock that has followed the news that Hong Kong supermarkets have been told to withdraw a local delicacy from their shelves.

Every day, millions of people around the world take the easy catering option and reach for a can of beans or a chewy dogburger.

But not me. While I'll always have a soft sport for a can of beans, my last-minute chowdown of choice is Pearl River Bridge Fried Dace With Salted Black Beans.

Pearl River Bridge dace on a plate
Pearl River Bridge Fried Dace With Salted Black Beans. A salty, oily paradise on a plate. Even adds taste to pak choi.

Throw some rice in the steamer, fry up any vegetable that comes to hand, and pop a can of this stuff into the microwave. If you’re feeling really adventurous, you can chop up the dace and mix it with some leafy vegetable and impress your family with your hitherto hidden culinary skills.

It doesn't have to be Pearl River Bridge. There are so many copycat brands, it's easy to grab the wrong one when you're in the supermarket - Eagle Coin, Jumbo, Yupin, Baoli, Golden Dragon - but Pearl River is the clear leader and market favourite.

It doesn’t even have to be served in black beans. There are varieties with curry, chilli, tofu, pepper, Chinese olives or just extra oil, but just as Pearl River Bridge is my choice of all the brands, their black bean flavour is the mother of all mud carp.

So what is this revolting looking black stuff?

For the benefit of the uninitiated, Dace in Black Bean is a staple of a million Hong Kong kitchen cupboards. It has a bit of a reputation as a low-class consumable, and I know few people who’ll admit to enjoying it, but whatever the reputation, this is one of the tastiest treats you’ll find in any canned food section.

In the words of Zhongshang Baoli Foodstuffs, one of the better-known dace makers, fried dace is “characterized by natural tint, tight texture and delicious taste… It is actually optimum for household use, travel and present”.

Like many of the best recipes, dace in black beans is a simple food: Two or three dried, salted mud carp, soaked in a mixture of salty fermented black soya beans, soy sauce, secret spices and some kind of vegetable oil. It could be sump oil, but if it is, then it's salted sump oil.

In short, it's heart-disease in a can. In one meal, you get more salt than your body can safely digest in a month, a concentration of pollutants that can only come from a Chinese river, and several desert-spoons full of oil. It's a heart attack, ulcers and bowel cancer, all in one handy portable package.

That’s fine by my digestive system, because it's not something I'd want to eat every day.

But thanks to the Hong Kong government’s insistence on its right to interfere in Hong Kong kitchens, it's a food you soon may not be able to eat at all.

In August, the government as is its wont, followed the lead of governments elsewhere and banned the import of foods containing malachite green – an industrial dye often used to protect fish from parasites. 

The following month, retailers were quietly asked to withdraw three batches of canned fish found to contain the chemical.

Despite passing a law against it just a month earlier, authorities were so unconcerned about the health impact, they didn’t bother telling the public until last week, and even then, they tried to avoid mentioning the suspect foods by name.

The Standard listed the accused brands as Pearl River Bridge, Yu Pin Mei Cai and Gulong, while the South China Morning Post translated the latter pair as Royal and Koolung.

The Chinese press, not surprisingly, were all over the story like a tumour. 

How Apple Daily saw the crisisThe Sun holds two brands to account
Apple Daily gave the fish a big splash The Sun put two culprits on display  - Yupin (L) and Pearl River Bridge (R)

 
Incidentally, the news prompted Guangdong Foodstuffs, the makers of Yupin dace, to issue a broadside against the makers of Pearl River Bridge Fried Dace. In China’s chaotic world of intellectual property, it’s not unusual for several state firms to share a single trademark. Interesting that. I'd always wondered why the sauces had a hologram but the dace didn't.

Guangdong Foodstuffs didn’t actually deny the fact their fish had been named as well.

The South China Morning Post followed up on the government's admission with the breathless revelation that a woman calling a radio phone-in had bought four cans after the withdrawal. 'This is unbelievable. What if I caught cancer?' the panicking shopper had asked.

What the Post failed to note was that the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department has calculated that "significant adverse health effects due to MG are not expected even when a person consumes up to 290 kg of freshwater fish each day".

Now, I like a bit of fish as much as anyone, but 290 kilograms in a day? That’s enough for 1,576 tins of fried dace. Actually, it makes even more, since the oil doesn’t contain malachite green.

So in order to suffer any adverse health effects from my favourite tea-time snack, you’d have to force your face through a tin a minute for 24 hours.

By that point it’s probably safe to assume, you may not be a healthy gourmet.

So if the Post’s concerned citizen should see this article, madam, don’t worry, you’ve got another 1,572 cans to get through today without any risk of ‘catching’ cancer.

Besides, is cancer such a bad thing? How many foods don't cause cancer? Salt causes cancer, and so does sugar. That healthy glass of milk? Cancer. A nice beer or a glass of wine? Cancer.

Meat’s an invitation for carcinoma, especially when it's cooked. Potatoes will kill you in no time, particularly when fried. Dim sum? Cancer. Cantonese food? What do you think?

In fact, if you eat anything that originates in China, you're almost certain to be ingesting cancerous additives not intended for human consumption. There's bleach in noodles, parasites in kimchi, pesticides in vegetables, everything imaginable in canned meat - it's a wonder anyone ever leaves a Chinese restaurant alive.

 A million varieties of dace on the shelves
There's a million varieties of dace in black bean, but only three of them got caught. Clockwise from top left; Pearl River Bridge, Yupin, Eagle Coin, Baoli, Jumbo and Golden Dragon. Can you spot the evil fish?
 


Quote this article on your site

Comments (11)
RSS comments
1. 28-03-2007 14:48
 
I'm currently a freshmen at St. Johns University in Queens,NY. I'm a 2nd generation Chinese American who grew up in upstate New York but loved this stuff. Whenever dinner, which always consisted of rice, didn't have enough to fill up the family, we'd pop one of these open. Now that I'm in school, I buy them religiously and feast on them over rice. Despite being delicious, they are incredibly packed w/ sodium and are swimming in oil. Don't that that stop you...So good.
Guest
 
Derek
2. 12-07-2007 03:48
 
Before losing the thread to a software glitch, there were several people who posted here about how they learned to love dace in black bean when they'd been short of cash. Same with me. Many years ago, I was living in Hong Kong on a pittance, and dace and rice made more economic sense than pasta and pesto. 
 
Thus began what I've no doubt will be a life-long love.
Registered
 
Thing
3. 12-07-2007 03:51
 
Meanwhile I returned to this page because a stranger mailed me to ask: "Hello. My name is Harold I am interested in buing about 20 cans of dace fish.can you provide me with a company that sells dace fish on internet".  
 
Harry, you sound so much like a spammer, but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. But if you don't say where the fish must be delivered, how can I answer? 
 
Both Park n Shop and Wellcome deliver.
Registered
 
Thing
4. 16-07-2007 01:13
 
So are these products still banned? I have found one store in Montreal that sells it so far - is this against the law? Are there places still buying this product, or will they ever start producing them without the MG in them? 
just don't want to see the rest of my life frantically searching for this...
Guest
 
jade
5. 18-07-2007 13:12
 
Now there's the funny thing. Because they weren't off the shelves for long in Hong Kong, and I don't think the government ever mentioned the subject again.  
 
Maybe they realised that China produces so many truly dangerous foodstuffs to worry about, and a ban on fried dace would likely result in social turmoil and street protests.
Registered
 
Thing
6. 23-07-2007 07:51
 
Yum! Dace with Rice
I have been wondering if I should toss the several tins I have. This is the best snack food I know. 
A Chinese grocery store here in Cleveland Ohio still has shelves of the yumage. 
Perhaps I'll forego this pleasure (and repack my emergency travel bag) with some other stick-to-the-ribs snack.
Guest
 
Omar_Pettiwigg
7. 23-07-2007 13:00
 
Yum! Dace with Rice
Hey Omar, the best place to toss your tins is straight into the frying pan. Why waste such a tasty treat? 
 
/ yumage is a good word.
Registered
 
Thing
8. 28-07-2007 04:24
 
Yum! Dace with Rice
My mom used to love to cook this up with rice when she wanted me to eat vegetable. It always seemed like my special treat when we were low on cash. Way better than sardines, who cares about the "cancer"?
Guest
 
Maxiebob
9. 09-02-2008 01:16
 
WOW
Omg i am so sorry i have to almost be rude but that stuff looks so revolting it makes me want to reguritate.I know some people have different preference and likes but how can anyone wanna eat that? Personally i just hate fish but whatever.... Alright thanks write me back! :upset :x
Guest
 
Jess Brant
10. 09-02-2008 01:16
 
WOW
imagine the smell of that.... GROSS! :upset
Guest
 
Jess
11. 25-02-2008 13:44
 
GROSS but GOOD
Hey Jess, I know what you mean. This is a food that you have to experience to really enjoy. I don\'t enjoy other fish because of the bones that can stick to my throat. But Fried Dace bones can be eaten without any problems. Just open a can, pour into a dish, cut up the fish into 1/2 inch pieces and use as a spicy ingredient if your other meal items are bland, such as tofu, rice, carrots, etc. :)
Guest
 
AAUGH

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
  • Personal verbal attacks will be deleted.
  • Please don't use comments to plug your web site. Such material will be removed.
  • Just ensure to *Refresh* your browser for a new security code to be displayed prior to clicking on the 'Send' button.
  • Keep in mind that the above process only applies if you simply entered the wrong security code.
Name:
E-mail
Homepage
Title:
BBCode:Web AddressEmail AddressBold TextItalic TextUnderlined TextQuoteCodeOpen ListList ItemClose List
Comment:



Code:* Code

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.3
AkoComment © Copyright 2004 by Arthur Konze - www.mamboportal.com
All right reserved




Share the joy
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Fark!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!

Last update : 18-12-2005 15:22

Quote this article in website Favoured Print Send to friend Related articles Save this to del.icio.us

Users' Comments  RSS feed comment
 

Average user rating

 

Display 11 of 11 comments

1. 25-02-2008 13:44

GROSS but GOOD
Hey Jess, I know what you mean. This is a food that you have to experience to really enjoy. I don't enjoy other fish because of the bones that can stick to my throat. But Fried Dace bones can be eaten without any problems. Just open a can, pour into a dish, cut up the fish into 1/2 inch pieces and use as a spicy ingredient if your other meal items are bland, such as tofu, rice, carrots, etc. :)
AAUGH

2. 09-02-2008 01:16

...
imagine the smell of that.... GROSS! :upset
Jess

3. 09-02-2008 01:16

WOW
Omg i am so sorry i have to almost be rude but that stuff looks so revolting it makes me want to reguritate.I know some people have different preference and likes but how can anyone wanna eat that? Personally i just hate fish but whatever.... Alright thanks write me back! :upset :x
Jess Brant

4. 28-07-2007 04:24

...
My mom used to love to cook this up with rice when she wanted me to eat vegetable. It always seemed like my special treat when we were low on cash. Way better than sardines, who cares about the "cancer"?
Maxiebob

5. 23-07-2007 13:00

...
Hey Omar, the best place to toss your tins is straight into the frying pan. Why waste such a tasty treat? 
 
/ yumage is a good word.
Thingfish

6. 23-07-2007 07:51

Yum! Dace with Rice
I have been wondering if I should toss the several tins I have. This is the best snack food I know. 
A Chinese grocery store here in Cleveland Ohio still has shelves of the yumage. 
Perhaps I'll forego this pleasure (and repack my emergency travel bag) with some other stick-to-the-ribs snack.
Omar_Pettiwigg

7. 18-07-2007 13:12

...
Now there's the funny thing. Because they weren't off the shelves for long in Hong Kong, and I don't think the government ever mentioned the subject again.  
 
Maybe they realised that China produces so many truly dangerous foodstuffs to worry about, and a ban on fried dace would likely result in social turmoil and street protests.
Thingfish

8. 16-07-2007 01:13

...
So are these products still banned? I have found one store in Montreal that sells it so far - is this against the law? Are there places still buying this product, or will they ever start producing them without the MG in them? 
just don't want to see the rest of my life frantically searching for this...
jade

9. 12-07-2007 03:51

...
Meanwhile I returned to this page because a stranger mailed me to ask: "Hello. My name is Harold I am interested in buing about 20 cans of dace fish.can you provide me with a company that sells dace fish on internet".  
 
Harry, you sound so much like a spammer, but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. But if you don't say where the fish must be delivered, how can I answer? 
 
Both Park n Shop and Wellcome deliver.
Thingfish

10. 12-07-2007 03:48

...
Before losing the thread to a software glitch, there were several people who posted here about how they learned to love dace in black bean when they'd been short of cash. Same with me. Many years ago, I was living in Hong Kong on a pittance, and dace and rice made more economic sense than pasta and pesto. 
 
Thus began what I've no doubt will be a life-long love.
Thingfish

11. 28-03-2007 14:48

...
I'm currently a freshmen at St. Johns University in Queens,NY. I'm a 2nd generation Chinese American who grew up in upstate New York but loved this stuff. Whenever dinner, which always consisted of rice, didn't have enough to fill up the family, we'd pop one of these open. Now that I'm in school, I buy them religiously and feast on them over rice. Despite being delicious, they are incredibly packed w/ sodium and are swimming in oil. Don't that that stop you...So good.
Derek

Display 11 of 11 comments

Add your comment



mXcomment 1.0.9 © 2007-2010 - visualclinic.fr
License Creative Commons - Some rights reserved
< Prev   Next >
Net Newswire
China's moonshot revealed as dodgy Photoshop

china-simp-75.jpgJust a week after Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao unveiled China's first Moon photo, a sleuthing spaceblogger has discovered Mr Wen may have been hiding something. "Chinese people's dream of flying to the moon for more than 1,000 years is beginning to materialise" said Wen at the time. And apparently all they needed to realise that dream was a copy of Photoshop. 

Read more...
 
You can take anything you want
happychappy-75.gifLast year, a YouTuber uploaded the world's most entertaining keep-fit video, in which a George Costanza-lookalike with knickers on his head robbed a terrified Japanese woman. Three girls then jumped around a bit, demonstrating the vocabulary you'll need to protect yourself from a geeky gaijin armed with a nail file.
Read more...
 
For momentary sexual pleasure you go to great lengths
Rangi RamBollywood has a new star on the rise: his name is Nirodh and he's a dancing condom. In his first song and dance spectacular, Nirodh and his latex friends skip and frolic through hills and fields to remind us all that they're made in different colours with fragrance. Take it away Nirodh.
Read more...
 
Electric Eel Shock go Multivision!
electric-eel-shock-75.gifTired of those crappy little low-res YouTube screens? Electric Eel Shock , the world's favourite rock n roll monster from Japan, has a revolutionary solution - just like more Marshall stacks make more bass boom, more YouTube screens make more Eel Shock!
Read more...
 
Fish LOVE rock and roll!

electric-eel-shock-75.gifJapan's only olympic champion rock and roll fisherman, Aki, of the great Electric Eel Shock, embarks on a second in EES' ongoing heavy metal fishing adventures.

This time, he uses bait even more powerful than heavy metal.

Read more...
 
© 2010 Netnewsasia
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.